
Schaub is primed for a huge season...according to Bertsch
On today’s podcast we’ll be going over QBs so I thought I write a quick blog about my QB projections for the season.
Without further adieu:
QB Board
#1 Tom Brady
Randy Moss. Wes Welker. And now Joey Galloway and Greg Lewis. This should be the most prolific passing offense in the NFL, if history has told us anything. The big Super Bowl loss two years ago and the season-ending injury last year in week 1. Think Brady feels he has something to prove?
#2 Peyton Manning
Year in and year out, hands down the best field general in the game. Anthony Gonzales is a huge upgrade over Marvin Harrison. Reggie Wayne in his prime. Dallas Clark in slot/TE. Their D is average as is their running game. I see a ton of yardage and plenty of TDs for Peyton Manning. The coaching staff has turned over, which may have caused alarm, but former offensive coordinator (and only coordinator Manning has ever had) Tom Moore is back, as a “consultant” but it sounds like he’ll be running the show. There was some issue about NFL pensions that forced his early ‘retirement.’
#3 Drew Brees
Drew Brees has been the best and most consistent in the game, fantasy-wise, over the last three years. He is huge in New Orleans. Is he ready for a let-down? My gut says yes, but a let down for him may be just 28 TDs and 4,000 yards. He’s been over 4,400 yards in each of his three seasons with the Saints, with 26, 28 and 34 TDs. Wow. Why do I have him at #3? A hunch maybe. Though LT Jammal Brown is looking at a 4-8 week recovery from hernia surgery last week, and he does protect Drew’s blindspot.
#4 Matt Shaub
Here’s my reach, but hear me out. Schaub led the NFL in yardage over the last four games last season, averaging over 320 yards a game. He has the best WR in the game with Andre Johnson, and Kevin Walter is no slouch. Owen Daniels is a very talented TE and Steve Slaton emerged as a legitimate run threat last season. The coaching staff is in place. This is Schaub’s year.
#5 Philip Rivers
Rivers and the Chargers benefit from a soft schedule, an aging running game, talented WRs (Chambers - 5 TDs in first 5 games last season before injury) and Vincent Jackson and one of the best TEs in the game. Plus a returning coaching staff, which cannot be stressed enough in value. Rivers looks fine for another solid season.
#6 Kurt Warner
If Warner was, say, 10 years younger he’d have to be #1 or #2.
I think Kurt Warner has been on my roster every season since his time with the Giants. Why? Because I knew he had potential to do what he did last year. Last season I bought him for a dollar to back-up Jay Cutler and could not trade him fast enough (for Andre Johnson, not bad.) Why was I so hot to trade him you ask? Because he was ON MY BENCH and I was afraid any snap could be his last. But something happened to Kurt Warner last year that made me realize he wasn’t getting hurt. I can’t put it to words other than to say he started to look bigger, meaner and tougher. Almost like a half robot or something.
People will be down on Warner because of risk of injury. But keep this in mind, even if Warner goes down after 5 games, he could get you 5 wins in the 5 games he plays. He’s that good right now. So if he goes down, either make sure you have a nice back-up in place or start playing match-up QBs. Not a big deal in my book.
#7 Aaron Rodgers
Aaron Rodgers, along with Cutler and Favre benefit from a nice, gravy schedule. He proved himself last season with 4,038 yards passing and 28 TDs. He has Donald Driver, Greg Jennings and a solid running game. He does have a bit of a tenderfoot as injuries have plagued him in the past. Conservative pick with a lot of upside.
#8 Donny McNabb
Donny McNabb is another perennial performer, when he plays. He has a solid cast with DeSean Jackson, Kevin Curtis and Brent Celek at TE. Plus a strong running game and solid D. He may lose a few TDs to Michael Vick and the wildcat.
#9 Trent Edwards
I like Trent Edwards this season. For clue number one, just take a peak at what TO has done for his starting QBs stats in previous years. Jeff Garcia, Donovan McNabb and Tony Romo have all enjoyed career seasons with the supposed cancer. Plus he has Lee Evans on the other side. And let’s not forget the aggressive no-huddle offense being implemented, which usually leads to more passing yards and always leads to extra plays. And more plays means more opportunities. The O-Line is a concern, but I think Trent Edwards is going to be top 5 material this season. If you’re not convinced, tuck him away as a back-up and see what happens.
#10 Matt Ryan
Matt Ryan had a very solid rookie campaign with over 3400 yards passing and 16 TDs. The Falcons did benefit from an easy schedule, but he brings back Roddy White and Michael Jenkins. Plus the Falcons nabbed Tony Gonzales, who could be a huge part of this offense. Solid running game, solid D. Another conservative pick with tons of upside.
#11Tony Romo
Tony Romo is going to have a down year. It seems like the Cowboys are going to turn into a run-first team. TO is gone and Roy Willi is an average WR1, nothing more. There are no indications so far that Romo will enjoy the success he has in the last two seasons. Their O-Line is getting old, with all five starters over 30. Beware.
#12 Ben Roethlisburger
Can a two-time Super Bowl victor get some love, please? Not necessarily in fantasy-land. But Big Ben may surprise some people. He quietly threw for 3,300 yards and 17 TDs last season. Nothing too exciting. The Steelers are run-first, but they do score a lot of points, have a strong D and run game and it doesn’t take much to flip 4-6 rushing TDs into passing TDs. Plus Big Ben will run some in.
#13 Jay Cutler
I want to give Jay Cutler a season in Chicago before talking him up. He’s in a new system with a new team, doesn’t have much for WRs. He does have a capable TE in Greg Olsen, who I am very interested in, and a great back in Matt Forte. Plus the Bears have that nice schedule. But I’ll be taking a wait and see approach on Cutler and let someone else grab him based on last season’s numbers. He is a streaky QB who when things don’t go well early sinks into oblivion. And he doesn’t have Brandon Marshall to throw to anymore.
#14 Carson Palmer
Carson Palmer may surprise some people this season, you never know. He is a former elite passer who has had some forgettable season and injuries. He lost his top target TJ Houshmanzadah to free agency. I don’t know what else to say. Can you say mediocre?
#15 Eli Manning
Don’t let the big contract fool you. Eli is a game manager in a run-first offense with little talent to throw to. Let some other sucker take him. A very conservative pick with little upside. Expect another 3,000 yard, 21 TD performance from the whiny face in NY.